At present, Althusser’s philosophy as a whole is undergoing a contradiction, uneven development, and overdetermination is that of the. In Althusser the need for a concept of overdetermination appears in Marxism at the point where the ideology of simple and general contradictions is undermined . Abstract, This article has no associated abstract. (fix it). Keywords, No keywords specified (fix it). Categories. Louis Althusser in Continental Philosophy.
|Published (Last):||1 July 2007|
|PDF File Size:||8.71 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||8.92 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
This oerdetermination in Catholicism and his participation in Catholic organizations would continue even after Althusser joined the Communist Party in Instead, he contends that Marx is guilty of committing the same error as Hegel in mistaking historical content for the fulfillment of the dialectic.
We could therefore take over the dialectic from him and apply it to life rather than to the Idea. Contradictions of large-scale capitalist and imperialist exploitation in the major cities and their suburbs, in the mining regions, oil-fields, etc. How are these new overdeterminatioon arranged? And how many peremptory attacks on economism althussef are to counterbalance that well-thumbed piece on the steam engine! Goshgarian in Philosophy of the Encounter: For these reasons, it is natural when discussing these texts to focus upon the contexts that engendered them and upon the positions within Marxist philosophy that Althusser stakes out by their means.
Three Varieties of Causal Overdetermination. Both also anticipate future concerns in their overdeterminwtion about the ideological character of current scientific knowledge and in their incorporation of ideas from Mao about the relationship between theory and practice.
The Marxist philosopher Louis Althusser imported the concept into Marxist political theory in an influential essay, “Contradiction and overdetermination. This gambit to have the Party directed by theorists rather than by a Overdeterminatiob Committee whose Stalinism remained entrenched and who believed in the organic wisdom of the worker met with little success. Classic Work — With the perspective afforded by the mass of posthumous writings published since the s, it has become clear that Althusser was perennially concerned with important issues in metaphysics, althusswr, philosophy of science, historiography, hermeneutics, and political philosophy.
Presses Universitaires de France,— Further, though some order must exist in order to allow for the production and reproduction of social life, there is no essential or best form that this order must contradictiln. After this service was up, his father returned to Algiers and to his work as a banker. Each of these essays includes the suggestion that critique and reform will occasion a better church and a truer Christianity.
We must carry this through to its conclusion and say that this overdetermination does not just refer to apparently unique and aberrant historical situations Germany, for examplebut is universal; the economic dialectic is never active in the pure state ; in History, these instances, the superstructures, etc.
I could go further, and suggest that in the well-known passage: Enhanced bibliography for this entry at PhilPaperswith links to its database. In scientific production, for example, thinkers use existing theories to transform existing concepts into new, scientific concepts.
Louis Althusser in Continental Philosophy categorize this paper. But this is not the case.
Let us return to Lenin and thence to Marx. Finally, this Marxism has given up the dream of analyzing the whole of culture and its movement from the outside; it realizes that one thinks inside and about the culture one inhabits in order to possibly effect and change that culture. Open access to the SEP is made althjsser by a world-wide funding initiative.
For Hegel, material life civil society, that is, the economy is merely a Ruse of Reason. To some readers, these revisions represented a politically motivated betrayal of his theoretical accomplishments.
This means, for instance, that some economic elements within a whole may be more or less capitalistic while others simultaneously operate according to socialist norms. It took a long time before Althusser explicitly addressed the charge that he had ignored much of what Marx had to say about his own logic and concepts.
These included the Humanist interpretations of Marx described above as well as variations on the orthodox Marxist-Leninist theory, which specified the strict determination of culture and history by the existing modes of economic exchange and resulting class struggles. The Overdetermination Argument Against Eliminativism. He also wishes to return to and bolster the thesis he first ventured in the late s that there are really only two positions in philosophy: Indeed, the only book-length study Althusser published during his lifetime was a work on Montesquieu, which appeared at the end of the decade.
Or does altuhsser refer as much to other structurespolitical. Any similarity here to Kuhnian ideas about revolutionary and normal science is not surprising. It includes not only an analysis of the state and its legal and educational systems but also of the psychological relationship which exists cotnradiction subject and state as ideology.
Without knowing it, as at last it died to bring forth its Roman future, it was already Rome, so it never shackled Rome in Rome. This page was last edited on 6 Aprilat Begun to treat recurrent bouts of depression, this last affiliation continued for the rest of contraxiction life and included ovfrdetermination hospitalization as well as the most aggressive treatments post-war French psychiatry had to offer such as electroconvulsive therapy, narco-analysis, and psychoanalysis.
The unevenness of capitalist development led, via the War, to the Russian Revolution because in the revolutionary situation facing the whole of humanity Russia was the weakest link in the chain of imperialist states.
Though both states and individuals are important elements of ckntradiction socio-economic whole, nothing philosophical is learned by examining the essence of the individual or the way in which justice is embodied by the state. That is, there are more causes present than are necessary to cause the effect.
Overdetermination – Wikipedia
It seems to me that this clarifies the expression overdetermined contradictionwhich I have put forward, this specifically because the existence of overdetermination is no longer a fact pure and simple, for in its essentials we have overdeterminaion it to its baseseven if our ovedetermination has so far been merely gestural.
Eric Yang – – Philosophical Studies 2: We are now concerned with the dialecticand the dialectic alone. History of Western Philosophy.
They derive from the relations of production, which are, of course, one of the terms of the contradiction, but at the same time its conditions of existence ; from the superstructures, instances which derive from it, but have their own consistency and effectivity from the international conjuncture itself, which intervenes as a determination with a specific role to play.
Presses universitaires de France.